What Inspires John Williams?

John Williams is known for his deep respect for the classical tradition and the history of film scoring, but he does not "steal" themes in the sense of outright plagiarism. Rather, he draws on the techniques and styles of earlier composers, and in some cases, his work may bear resemblance to earlier musical ideas. This is common in the world of classical and film music, where composers often take inspiration from or reference the music that came before them. There are a few key ways in which Williams might seem to reference or echo older pieces:

1. Influence of Classical Composers

Many of John Williams’ themes and orchestrations show clear influences from classical composers like Richard Strauss, Gustav Holst, John Williams' own predecessors (like Bernard Herrmann or Max Steiner), and even early 20th-century symphonic music. These influences often manifest in the orchestration, harmonic structure, and thematic development. For example:

• The "Star Wars" main theme, with its bold, brass-heavy fanfares, draws on the tradition of Wagnerian operatic themes and the grand, expansive styles of Richard Strauss and Holst’s "The Planets".

• The use of grand, sweeping strings and emotional themes in scores like "E.T." can be traced to the lush orchestrations of Tchaikovsky and Strauss, though the melodies themselves are Williams’ own.

This kind of influence isn't stealing—it's common in classical music for composers to engage with the past in this way. Williams has acknowledged in interviews that he’s heavily inspired by the past and views his work as part of a larger tradition.

2. Leitmotif and Homage

Williams frequently uses leitmotifs, a technique made famous by composers like Richard Wagner and later used by Max Steiner in film. A leitmotif is a recurring musical theme tied to a particular character, idea, or location, and it's a hallmark of Williams' work.

• For example, the famous "Indiana Jones" theme and the "Star Wars" themes are both built on variations of this technique. While these motifs may feel familiar, they are new compositions, with Williams adapting them to the specific needs of the films.

• "The Empire Strikes Back" score references and builds on the musical language of Wagner (especially with its use of grand brass and orchestral colors) in a way that feels inspired rather than derivative.

Williams has also been known to pay homages to earlier works or composers as a way of honoring them. For instance, there are passages in his music that intentionally evoke the sound of older works without copying them directly.

3. Thematic Similarities and Unconscious Echoes

There have been occasional discussions about specific thematic similarities between Williams' work and older music, but this is often the result of common musical language rather than direct copying. For instance:

• The "Jaws" theme, with its two-note motif, might feel similar to early 20th-century minimalist techniques or the tension-building approaches of composers like Hector Berlioz or Stravinsky, but it’s Williams’ original contribution to creating musical tension for a film.

• Some have pointed out that the opening of the "Star Wars" theme resembles music from Holst’s "The Planets," specifically the "Mars" movement, but again, Williams adapts these influences to fit his own narrative and cinematic vision.

4. Purposeful Borrowing

In some cases, Williams might choose to intentionally reference or quote from earlier works as a kind of musical “quotation” or nod to a previous composer or style. For example, in "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone," he uses orchestral textures that recall Ralph Vaughan Williams, and he integrates some traditional English folk-like tunes to evoke a certain English atmosphere. In this sense, it’s more like an artistic reference than theft.

Conclusion

While Williams' music sometimes draws from a rich tradition of classical and film music, he is widely regarded as an original composer. His use of established techniques and homage to past works is not considered "stealing," but rather a sign of his deep understanding and respect for the musical canon. He creates new music that echoes the past while fitting the needs of modern film storytelling, and his use of familiar ideas is often transformed into something uniquely his own.

4o mini